THERE ARE SPOILERS TO SCOTT PILGRIM VS THE WORLD (THE MOVIE) IN THIS JOURNAL. I just saw the movie but have not read the books, so this review is solely on the film. I do want to read the books to see how they compare, so please do not spoil the graphic novels for me.

So I went to see Scott Pilgrim Vs. the World today. It was a much-needed and welcomed break after a week of moving and settling into my new apartment. I needed some time out and I'd been told I'd love this movie, so I decided I should go see it.
Things to get out of the way: I enjoyed this movie a LOT. The style, the cleverness, the throwbacks to video games and comic books, all of it was fun, fantastic, polished and well-informed. Perfect homage to all of it. There were things only a few would get and things more open to general audiences. Overall, a fantastic film experience with a story and characters much deeper than I had been expecting. It was hard not to have high expectations when everyone was telling me that I'd love this movie and the film surprised me even more by surpassing those expectations. I really loved it.
Now, there was obviously something I didn't like as evidenced by this journal, and that was the ending. I didn't want Scott to end up with Ramona. Now I know she's the girl he's been fighting for the whole movie and she's exciting and mysterious and a bad girl, but halfway through the film I was already starting to feel that the film itself was pointing for Scott ending up with Knives. I'm not joking. At the very beginning he says that he likes being with Knives, it's comfortable and simple and nice. Then he meets Ramona and the danger starts. And not only is it dangerous, but she's kind of a jerk. She makes the calls on everything, she brings danger into his life and everyone around him, she is literally bad news.
Which brings me to my point: Scott Pilgrim's story is the male equivalent of Twilight. NO, Scott and Ramona are NOT AT ALL like Bella and Edward. They have a personality (well, at least Scott does.) The similarities really are in the story: okay guy, could be in a good relationship with a good girl, but he goes with the bad, mysterious one. Why? Because she's bad and mysterious. At first there's no other reason why. Then as we not only learn about her baggage of evil exes, but then her own issues with relationships and breaking people's hearts, there's even less reason to like her! But he still does. He shouldn't be with her, but he ends up with her. It perpetuates the very pinnacle of what is the Twilight paradox: be with the bad guy/girl, because, deep down, they have a heart and you can fix them. Everyone in Twilight tells Bella how bad Edward is for her, just as everyone in Scott Pilgrim tells Scott how bad Ramona is for him, and they both go against those warnings because the other is cool, mysterious and bad for them.
The entire film seemed to be pointing against Ramona and towards Knives for me. Ramona was never any good to or for Scott, and while Knives was underage, she cared for what Scott was doing and cared about him. It seemed to be one of those stories of what a person wants versus what they need. Scott wants an exciting, mysterious, bad girl but what he needs is a nice, caring, down-to-earth girl. And the film completely betrays itself on that one in the end.
Maybe I just don't understand "true love." I'm not saying love should be this Brady Bunch ideal, real couples do fight and it strengthens a relationship. But, in most cases, dating the "bad person" doesn't end up well. "Oh, he hits me because he's so troubled, but I know he loves me." I've had too many experiences with friends to think that entering into a relationship because you can fix someone's problems is a good idea. And I'm not saying even that I'm looking for someone perfect, just someone who's worked enough on themselves as I have on myself that won't depend solely on what I can do to "fix" them.
On a last note: Despite all her coolness, mystery and independence, by the end of the film Ramona was reduced to a damsel being fought over by two men. It's as if she has no role, no say in the matter, to even declare herself independent from whoever wins. She's the prize to be fought for, not a woman who can think for herself. I wasn't so upset that the guys were fighting over her, just that in all her cool and independent-ness, she never asserted her own wishes and desires, just left it up to whoever was the victor. She doesn't want people to get hurt fighting for her? Then make a damn choice!
I'd like to repeat, I did really, really, really like this film. Just, once the credits began rolling, my reaction was: 'Aww, really?'
PS. I want to marry Alison Pill.